Mar 30 2012
• Scheduled for briefing and discussion at the Public Safety, Civil Rights, & Technology Committee on Wednesday, 4/04/12, 2:00 pm.
• Council Bill 117416: AN ORDINANCE relating to Unfair Public Accommodation Practices; amending sections 14.06.020 and 14.06.030 to add the right of a mother to breastfeed her child in places of public accommodation free from discrimination.
Seattle Women’s Commission (SWC) Breastfeeding Fact Sheet:
• SWC has focused on addressing infant mortality for those communities disproportionally affected. Working with community partners such as the breastfeeding coalition of WA and the Equal Start Community Coalition we identified breastfeeding as an area in which to focus.
• In mid-year 2011 the US Surgeon General issues a call to action to support breastfeeding, this report cited research that shows that only 43% of American’s believe a mother should breastfeed in public. This research also cited restaurant managers, etc., who report they routinely ask breastfeeding mothers to leave, move or cover up. The mothers feel embarrassed and harassed and cite this as a cause to stop breastfeeding. This proposed legislation is supporting this federal call to action, specifically by working on a community identified issue.
(http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/topics/breastfeeding/calltoactiontosupportbreastfeeding.pdf see pg. 13).
• American Indians/Alaska Natives and African American women experience disproportionally high rates of infant mortality in at two and three times the rate of white women in Seattle. Breastfeeding is shown to reduce rates of infant mortality (SIDS), however by age 6 months only 13% of women are still breastfeeding. Breastfeeding has also been shown to reduce rates of obesity, diabetes and improve brain function just to cite a few additional benefits.
• In consulting with the WA Breastfeeding Coalition they shared the experiences of women who had experienced discrimination in public places such as restaurants, coffee shops and grocery stores. This was further expressed at the “The Liz Thomas Legacy Policy Summit to Eliminate Racial Disparities in Infant Mortality” where the goal to establish family friendly policies around breastfeeding was articulated. (see attached report pgs. 13-14, SWC was a member of the planning)
• The state has anti-discrimination breastfeeding law in place but many women didn’t know about it or how to file complaints. The WA Human Rights Commission (who enforces this law) suggested local enforcement would benefit those who were not aware of these laws and further support and protect them from discrimination. With the state budget cuts they have not been able to focus on outreach and education relating to this law.
• The proposed legislation would add breast feeding women to a class protected from discrimination in public accommodations. They would not be able to be told to leave, cover up or move to a secluded place to breastfeed.
• As part of their normal activities, SOCR will provide info on this at their tabling events and trainings. This provides a much needed educational piece for the public and those operating public spaces.
Frequently Asked Questions: Civil Rights Protection for Breastfeeding in Public in Seattle
What would this bill do?
If this bill becomes law, it would be a violation of City law to discriminate against someone who is breastfeeding in a public place. Individuals who feel their rights have been violated would be able to file a charge with the Seattle Office for Civil Rights, who would investigate the allegation.
Doesn’t Washington State already provide this protection throughout the state? Why is the City of Seattle taking this step?
Yes, the State of Washington has provided civil rights protection for breastfeeding in public since July 26, 2009. A City-level ordinance would reinforce this protection and allow the Seattle Office for Civil Rights to investigate cases that occur within Seattle. Currently a person who does not want to file through the courts can only file a charge of discrimination through the Washington State Human Rights Commission (WSHRC) in Olympia. WSHRC does not have a Seattle office, and due to severe budget cuts, the agency’s ability to provide outreach and education locally is extremely limited. City-level enforcement of the public breastfeeding law will help ensure equity for all women in Seattle.
What does the current Washington State law allow?
Under the ordinance, mothers can breastfeed at a time, place, and manner of their choosing while in a place of public accommodation. They do not have to go to a special area or go into the restroom. They do not have to cover the baby with a towel or blanket. The owner, manager, or employee of a public place cannot request that the mother stop breastfeeding her baby, cover up, move to a different room or area, or leave.
Why is this protection important?
Breastfeeding is a normal, regular and important part of raising a healthy baby. No one should have to use a restroom or stand outside simply to feed her own baby.
Breastfeeding discrimination is a race and social justice issue. As with many health indicators, race-based disparities exist in breastfeeding. Breastfeeding for the first six months of life reduces health risks for babies, particularly to the immune and digestive systems. In Seattle, communities of color experience the lowest breastfeeding rates and the highest rates of preterm birth, infant mortality, maternal mortality, diabetes and obesity. Infant mortality and low birth weight disproportionally affect Native American and African American women in King County.
Eliminating societal barriers to breastfeeding will enable more women to continue to breastfeed their children for longer. While 75% of U.S. babies start out breastfeeding, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says, only 13% are exclusively breastfed for the recommended six months. Increasing breastfeeding is difficult when women face discrimination for feeding their children in public. Low-income children, who are at the greatest risk for obesity, are also the least likely to be breastfed, even though formula feeding is considerably more expensive than breastfeeding. Low-income mothers are often those who are harassed for breastfeeding in public places, such as on public transportation.
Information on statewide protection for breastfeeding from the Washington State Human Rights Commission
The Washington State Human Rights Commission has created its own “Guide to Breastfeeding,” as well as materials such as wallet cards and flyers. The following are questions and answers from the Washington State Human Rights Commission about statewide protection for breastfeeding in public.
Questions businesses might ask:
Why doesn’t she use formula or express breastmilk and feed from a bottle?
The parents are the best people to make decisions about what and how to feed their child. There are numerous personal and health reasons for choosing one method of feeding over another, as well as for choosing breastmilk or formula. In addition, some babies do not tolerate a bottle and will not drink from one.
Why can’t the mother cover the baby when nursing?
Some children will not tolerate being covered with a towel or blanket, and will cry instead of eat. Some children need eye contact with their mother while breastfeeding, and others like to look around. These actions may also be related to a child’s normal development stage.
Can’t the mother go to the restroom to feed the baby?
No one should have to use a restroom other than for its intended purpose.
Is it dangerous for a baby to breastfeed in or next to a pool? Could breastmilk contaminate a pool?
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention clearly states that breastmilk is not a biohazard. A breastfeeding mother swimming in a pool or feeding her baby near a pool does not contaminate the pool or water in any way. It is safer for a mother and her children if the mother remains near the pool to watch her other children in the pool, than to have to breastfeed elsewhere. Rules regarding no food in or around pools should not apply to breastfeeding mothers.
What if other customers or patrons complain? Is that enough of a reason to ask the breastfeeding mother to leave or stop?
No. Complaints from other patrons or customers are not valid reasons for asking the mother to stop breastfeeding or to leave. Politely explain to the concerned customer that the law protects the right of the mother to stay where she is to breastfeed. If they are offended the only suggestion that you can make is for them to avert their eyes.
Would my business be in violation of the law if one of my employees asks a breastfeeding mother to leave, cover her child, or stop nursing?
Yes. The employees represent the business, and their actions can constitute a violation of the law. Make sure your employees know about this law. Share this guidance with them. In addition, the WSHRC and the Breastfeeding Coalition of Washington have created a poster to inform a business’s employees about this law. You can obtain a copy of this poster from the WSHRC website, and post it in your employee breakroom or with your other workplace postings.
Do I need to provide a special room or space for breastfeeding mothers?
No. You do not need to provide a room or separate space for breastfeeding mothers, although you may choose to do so. If you do, place prominent signs that such a room is available. If a mother chooses to breastfeed outside of that room, remember that it is her prerogative to do so under the law, and do not tell her to go to the room. If she has already started to feed her child, it may not be a good idea to interrupt and tell her that the room is available, as this may disrupt the child or make the mother uncomfortable. You can obtain a copy of the International Breastfeeding Symbol from the Internet if you would like families to know breastfeeding is welcome in your place of business.
Questions parents might ask:
What is a place of public accommodation?
It is any place of public resort, accommodation, assemblage or amusement. Generally, it is any place where members of the public can go to assemble, or obtain goods, entertainment, or services. This includes restaurants, coffee shops, public swimming pools, gyms and athletic clubs, movie theatres, government buildings, museums, libraries, busses, and parks. It does not include your place of employment. If an employer prohibits a woman from breastfeeding or pumping breastmilk at work, as an employee, the woman is not protected under this law. The incident would need to be addressed under employment discrimination laws, but at this time, breastfeeding is not protected under the Washington Law Against Discrimination’s employment provisions.
What do I do if I am breastfeeding and I am asked to leave, cover my baby, move, or stop nursing?
Take the opportunity to help inform others about the law that protects you. It’s very possible that the person talking to you doesn’t know about the law. The WSHRC and Breastfeeding Coalition of Washington have produced wallet cards for breastfeeding mothers. The card has information about the law, and can be presented to anyone who asks you to leave, move, cover your child, or stop nursing.
What if informing others about the law does not work, and I am still requested to leave, cover up my child, move or stop nursing?
You have the option of filing a complaint with the WSHRC. You can do this by calling the WSHRC (800-233-3247) or by going on-line to file a complaint at www.hum.wa.gov.
What if another customer or patron asks me to stop nursing or to go somewhere else?
The business itself cannot usually be held responsible for the actions of its patrons, so you could not file a complaint against the business in that situation (unless the business also stepped in and asked you to stop or leave). Politely explain your rights and show the person the wallet card. Try not to get angry or raise your voice, as you want to avoid a situation in which you are asked to leave because of your tone or demeanor.
If I have been discriminated against, when should I file my complaint?
If you were in a place of public accommodation, and were asked to leave, cover your child, move, or stop nursing, you need to file your complaint within six months of the incident. However, the sooner after the incident, the better.
What information do I need to file a complaint?
You need the name and address of the place of public accommodation and the date of the incident. You will also need to briefly explain what happened, and include your name and contact information, as well as contact information for any witnesses.
Where can I get a wallet card?
Limited hard copies are available from the WSHRC and the Breastfeeding Coalition of Washington. Wallet cards can also be printed from these organizations’ websites: www.hum.wa.gov and www.breastfeedingwa.org.
• “Fulfilling the Dream of Our Children” – The Liz Thomas Legacy Policy Summit to Eliminate Racial Disparities in Infant Mortality | Link to Report.